Group synergies

Example 17 — Parent guarantee on top of group membership

Chapter I · Example 2 (synergies) · ¶1.187 · P group

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
S would be rated only Baa on its own, but as a member of the P group it can borrow at the rate for A-rated borrowers without any formal guarantee. Its parent P, rated AAA, guarantees a EUR 50 million loan from Bank A to induce it to lend at the rate available to AAA-rated borrowers. Should S pay P a guarantee fee and, if so, for which benefit?
P
Parent · AAA rating · guarantor
express guarantee
Bank A
Lender
EUR 50 million loan
S
Borrower · Baa on a stand-alone basis

No formal guarantee is needed, the functional analysis suggests, for Bank A to lend to S at the rate for A-rated borrowers. What P's guarantee is meant to obtain is the rate available to AAA-rated borrowers.

  1. P, the parent of an MNE group in the financial services business, keeps an AAA credit rating thanks to the group's strong consolidated balance sheet (facts taken over from Example 1, ¶1.184).
  2. S, a group member, would merit only a Baa rating on its own balance sheet. As a member of the P group it can nevertheless borrow from large independent lenders at the interest rates charged to A-rated borrowers (also ¶1.184).
  3. S takes a EUR 50 million loan from Bank A. The functional analysis suggests that, even without a formal guarantee, Bank A would lend at the interest rate for A-rated borrowers.
  4. P nevertheless agrees to guarantee the loan, so as to induce Bank A to charge the interest rate it would offer an AAA-rated borrower.

The functional analysis suggests Bank A would lend S the EUR 50 million at the rate for A-rated borrowers with no formal guarantee, though S's own balance sheet would support only Baa. P's express guarantee is meant to secure the rate for AAA-rated borrowers.

Should S pay P a guarantee fee and, if so, for which benefit?

OECD analysis · Fee for A to AAA
For P's express guarantee, S should be required to pay P a fee. The arm's-length fee should reflect only the improvement the guarantee itself brings, from A to AAA, not the whole distance from S's stand-alone Baa to AAA. The step from Baa to A is a synergy from purely passive association with the group, which under this section need not be compensated; the step from A to AAA exists only because P provided the guarantee, a deliberate concerted action, and should be compensated. A footnote cautions that the example is not comprehensive guidance on guarantee fees and refers to Chapter X.
Key takeaway
Split the benefit by its source: what a borrower gains from passive association with its group need not be paid for, while what it gains from a deliberate concerted action, such as a parent's express guarantee, should be. By its own footnote, the example is not comprehensive guidance on guarantee fees.

Related: ¶1.184–1.186 (Example 1: the same borrower without a guarantee) · Chapter X (transfer pricing aspects of financial transactions) · Section D.8 (MNE group synergies)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →