Group synergies
Example 16 — Borrowing on the strength of group membership
Chapter I · Example 1 (synergies) · ¶1.184–1.186 · P group
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
On its own S would be rated only Baa, but because it belongs to the P group, whose parent is rated AAA, large independent lenders lend to it at the rates charged to A-rated borrowers. S takes a EUR 50 million loan from an independent lender and, at the same time and rate, another EUR 50 million from T, a fellow subsidiary. Is T's rate arm's-length?
The parties
T
Subsidiary of P · lenderEUR 50 million loan
S
Borrower · Baa on a stand-alone basis · borrows on A-rated termsAt the same time an independent lender lends S another EUR 50 million; terms, conditions and interest rate are the same. P, the parent, maintains an AAA rating.
What happens
- A financial services MNE group has P as its parent company. Because the group's consolidated balance sheet is strong, P is able to keep an AAA credit rating consistently.
- S belongs to the group and offers the same type of financial services as other members, with large-scale operations in an important market. Judged on its own balance sheet, S would merit a rating of only Baa.
- Membership of the P group nevertheless means that large independent lenders will lend to S at the interest rates they would charge an independent A-rated borrower.
- An independent lender lends S EUR 50 million at the market interest rate for A-rated borrowers. It sets its terms and conditions aware that S has other borrowings, the simultaneous loan from T among them.
- Simultaneously T, which like S is a subsidiary of P and has characteristics similar to the independent lender's, lends S a further EUR 50 million; its terms, conditions and interest rate match the independent lender's.
Analysis
T lends S EUR 50 million; its terms, conditions and interest rate match those of an independent lender that lends S the same amount at the same time. The rate is the market rate for A-rated borrowers, which S obtains because it is a member of the P group.
Is the interest rate on T's loan an arm's-length rate?
OECD analysis · Arm's-length, no adjustment
The rate T charges is an arm's-length rate, for two reasons. First, an independent lender charged S the very same rate in a comparable transaction. Second, S's ability to borrow from independent enterprises more cheaply than it could outside the group is a synergy that flows from group membership alone: no member of the group took any deliberate concerted action to bring it about, so it calls for neither a payment nor a comparability adjustment.
Key takeaway
A synergy benefit that arises purely from group membership, without deliberate concerted action or any service or other function performed by group members, need not be separately compensated or allocated, whatever its size (¶1.178). An independent lender's rate on a comparable loan can then be used unadjusted.
Related: Section D.8 (MNE group synergies) · ¶1.178 and ¶7.13 (incidental benefits of group membership) · ¶1.187 (Example 2: P adds an express guarantee)