Non-recognition
Example 15 — Lump sum for twenty years of future intangibles
Chapter I · Example 2 (non-recognition) · ¶1.148 · Company S1 · Company S2
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
Company S1 develops intangibles through research and uses them for new products that it can make and sell. For a lump sum, it agrees to transfer to Company S2, an associated company, unlimited rights to every future intangible that may come out of its work over twenty years. Can the arrangement be priced as it stands and, if not, what replaces it?
The parties
Company S1
Conducts research · develops intangibles for new productsunlimited rights to all future intangibles
Company S2
Associated company · pays a lump sumThe rights extend to whatever intangibles Company S1's future work may produce during a twenty-year period.
What happens
- Company S1 carries out research to develop intangibles and uses them to create new products, which it can manufacture and sell.
- It agrees to transfer to Company S2, an associated company, unlimited rights to every future intangible that may result from its future work during a period of twenty years.
- In return, Company S2 makes a lump sum payment.
- The range of development activities that Company S1 may carry on during those twenty years is uncertain.
Analysis
Neither company can reliably determine whether the lump sum reflects an appropriate valuation: the range of Company S1's development activities over the twenty years is uncertain, and any valuation of the possible outcomes would be entirely speculative.
How should the arrangement be dealt with in the transfer pricing analysis?
OECD analysis · Structure should be modified
Neither party can reliably judge whether the payment reflects an appropriate valuation, which makes the arrangement commercially irrational for both. Its structure, form of payment included, should be modified to the one most consistent with the facts, guided by functions, assets, risks and the other economically relevant characteristics. No single replacement is named: depending on the facts, it could be financing by Company S2, research services by Company S1 or, where specific intangibles are identifiable, a licence with contingent payment terms for developing them, with the guidance on hard-to-value intangibles taken into account as appropriate.
Key takeaway
An arrangement that neither party has a reliable means of valuing may be commercially irrational; then its structure, not merely its price, is modified. The replacement should stay as close as possible to the actual facts while achieving a commercially rational result on which the parties could have agreed a price (¶1.144).
Related: Section D.2 (recognition of the accurately delineated transaction) · ¶1.146–1.147 (Example 1: insurance where there is no market) · Section D.4 of Chapter VI (hard-to-value intangibles)