Non-recognition

Example 14 — Insuring a flood-prone property within the group

Chapter I · Example 1 (non-recognition) · ¶1.146–1.147 · Company S1 · Company S2

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
Company S1, a manufacturer, owns commercial property in an area of increasingly frequent flooding, where there is no active market for property insurance. An associated enterprise, Company S2, insures it for an annual premium of 80% of the value of the inventory, property and contents. Should the insurance be priced, or not recognised at all?
Company S1
Manufacturer · owns property in a flood-prone area
annual premium
Company S2
Associated enterprise · provides the insurance

The annual premium equals 80% of what the inventory, property and contents are worth, in an area where property insurance has no active market.

  1. Company S1 is a manufacturer whose business requires it to hold substantial inventory and to invest significantly in plant and machinery.
  2. It owns commercial property in an area prone to flooding, which has become increasingly frequent in recent years.
  3. Third-party insurers are significantly uncertain about their exposure to large claims, so there is no active market for insuring properties in the area.
  4. Company S1 is insured by an associated enterprise, Company S2, and pays it each year a premium equal to 80% of the value of the inventory, property and contents.

There is no market for insuring properties in the area, given the likelihood of significant claims. Company S1 still takes insurance from Company S2, at an annual premium of 80% of the value of the inventory, property and contents.

How should the insurance be treated for transfer pricing purposes?

OECD analysis · Not recognised
Significant claims are likely, which is why no market for this insurance exists, and S1 may have more attractive realistic alternatives in relocating or in going uninsured. The Guidelines therefore regard the transaction as commercially irrational, so that no price exists that both S1 and S2 would accept from their own perspectives. It should not be recognised: for transfer pricing purposes it is as if S1 had bought no insurance, so the payment to S2 does not reduce its profits, and as if S2 had issued none, so S2 is not liable for any claim.
Key takeaway
A transaction may be disregarded where, viewed as a whole, it differs from what commercially rational independent enterprises would have agreed, so that no price acceptable to both parties can be determined. That it is hard to price, or is not seen between independent parties, is not enough (¶1.142).

Related: Section D.2 (recognition of the accurately delineated transaction) · ¶1.142–1.143 (when a transaction may be disregarded) · ¶1.148 (Example 2: twenty years of future intangibles for a lump sum)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →