Risk-free and risk-adjusted returns
Example 13 — Funding an intangible without the development risk
Chapter I · ¶1.119 · Company F · Company D
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
Company F lends to Company D, an associated enterprise that is developing an intangible. Company F controls the financial risk, including the risk of not being repaid if Company D fails to develop the intangible, but the development risk is entirely Company D's. If the intangible earns more or less than projected, is the difference Company F's?
The parties
Company F
Lender · controls and is allocated the financial riskloan
Company D
Borrower · develops the intangible · assumes the development riskWhat happens
- Company F makes a loan to Company D, an associated enterprise that is developing an intangible.
- It is determined under Chapter I that Company F controls, and so is allocated, the financial risk of funding the development, including the risk that Company D fails to develop the intangible and therefore cannot repay the loan.
- The development risk is not Company F's: as the transaction is accurately delineated, Company D assumes all of it.
- Once the developed intangible is exploited, actual results may come out above or below those calculated beforehand.
Analysis
Company F, the lender, has control of the financial risk on its loan, while the development risk lies wholly with the borrower, Company D. Exploiting the developed intangible then yields results above, or below, those calculated ex ante.
What is Company F entitled to?
OECD analysis · Risk-adjusted return only
The financial risk a funder assumes in its financing activity must be told apart from the operational risk tied to the use of the funds, here the development of the intangible (¶1.118). Company F controls and is allocated the first, including the risk that Company D fails to develop the intangible and so cannot repay. It did not assume the second, so the gap between the results calculated ex ante and those actually derived from exploiting the intangible, up or down, is not Company F's. Its entitlement is a risk-adjusted rate of return: in general, the risk-free rate plus a premium for the risks the funder assumes (¶1.120).
Key takeaway
A funder that controls the financial risk of its funding, and no other specific risk, can generally expect only a risk-adjusted return (¶1.117, quoting ¶6.61). The difference between projected and actual results of the funded activity is tied to the operational risk, which the funder did not assume, so it is not the funder's.
Related: Section D.1.2.2.2 (determining a risk-adjusted rate of return) · ¶6.60–6.64 (funding and the risks of the activity funded) · ¶1.85 and ¶1.103 (Example 3 on risk: a funder limited to a risk-free return)