Risk-free and risk-adjusted returns

Example 12 — Reference rates for risk-free and risk-adjusted returns

Chapter I · ¶1.114, 1.125 · Company A · Company B

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
Company A, resident in Country X, makes a one-year advance of funds to Company B, an associated enterprise. Country X's tax administration must estimate Company A's return: first where Company A is entitled to no more than a risk-free return, then where it is entitled to a risk-adjusted return. Which market rates may it look to?
Company A
Funder · MNE group member · resident in Country X
advance of funds · one-year term
Company B
Associated enterprise · receives the funds

Country X's tax administration finds three one-year government securities in Company A's functional currency: Country X (government rated A), Country Y (rated B) and Country Z (rated AA).

  1. Company A belongs to an MNE group and makes a one-year advance of funds to Company B, an associated enterprise.
  2. Company A is resident in Country X. To approximate its return, Country X's tax administration looks for a security issued when the funding was provided and denominated in Company A's functional currency.
  3. It finds three one-year securities in that currency, issued by the governments of Country X (rated A), Country Y (rated B) and Country Z (rated AA).
  4. Of all outstanding one-year government bonds in that currency, the Country Z security offers the lowest rate of return when the funding is provided.
A

Company A's entitlement on its one-year advance to Company B is capped at a risk-free return. Three one-year government securities exist in its functional currency: Country X's (issuer rated A), Country Y's (rated B) and Country Z's (rated AA).

Which security may the tax administration take as its reference for the risk-free rate?

OECD analysis · May use Country Z's security
In setting the minimum credit rating an issuer needs for its security to count as a risk-free investment, the tax administration may select the Country Z security: of all outstanding one-year government bonds in Company A's functional currency, it offers the lowest return available when the funding is provided. Where several governments issue in one currency, a difference in rate can only reflect a difference in issuer risk; the investor's functional currency counts, not its domicile (¶1.111). This is a practical solution: other references, such as interbank rates or interest rate swap rates, may also be considered on the facts (¶1.115).
B

Here Company A's entitlement is found to be a risk-adjusted rate of return, and the one-year Country Z security serves as the risk-free rate. Independent parties resident in Country X and active in Company B's industry have issued corporate bonds.

What approach does the tax administration consider for estimating the risk-adjusted return?

OECD analysis · Risk-free rate plus premium
A funder that assumes the financial risk is exposed to its upside and downside, which warrants an expected return above the risk-free rate (¶1.121). The approach the tax administration considers is the risk-free rate, taken from the one-year Country Z security, plus a risk premium. As its yardstick it takes the corporate bonds of independent issuers resident in Country X in Company B's industry, whose yield it considers comparable to the return an independent investor would have expected from funding Company B in comparable circumstances. The Guidelines give no figures and present the premium as one of several possible approaches (¶1.122–1.124).
Key takeaway
A risk-free return can be approximated from a government security in the funder's functional currency with a matching term: where several governments issue in that currency, the lowest return is the reference point. A funder that assumes the financial risk expects more, for instance that rate plus a market-based risk premium.

Related: Section D.1.2.2 (risk-free and risk-adjusted rates of return) · ¶1.111–1.113 (currency, timing and maturity of the reference security) · Section C.1.2 of Chapter X (arm's-length interest rate of intra-group loans)

Test yourself on this example, question by question.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →