Risk analysis in six steps

Example 11 — Exchange rate risk on paper and in practice

Chapter I · ¶1.89 · Manufacturer · distributor

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
The functional currency of a manufacturer is the US dollar; that of the associated distributor to which it sells goods is the euro. The written contract puts all exchange rate risks on the distributor, yet over an extended period the manufacturer charges for the goods in euros. Which decides who assumes the risk: the contract or the conduct?
Manufacturer
Functional currency: US dollars
goods, charged in euros
Distributor
Associated enterprise in another jurisdiction · functional currency: euros
  1. A manufacturer with the US dollar as its functional currency sells goods to a distributor in another jurisdiction. The distributor is an associated enterprise and has the euro as its functional currency.
  2. Their written contract provides that all exchange rate risks relating to this controlled transaction are assumed by the distributor.
  3. Over an extended period of time, the manufacturer charges the distributor for the goods in euros, the distributor's own currency.

On paper, all exchange rate risks of the transaction lie with the distributor. In practice the manufacturer has charged for the goods in euros, the distributor's own currency, over an extended period.

What determines who assumes the exchange rate risk in this transaction?

OECD analysis · Conduct, not unapplied terms
Step 4(i) asks whether the parties act in line with the assumption of risk set out in their written contract (¶1.88). If the manufacturer charges for the goods in the distributor's own currency over an extended period, the written terms do not, in that respect, reflect what actually goes on between the parties. Who assumes the risk should then be decided by what the parties actually do, read in the context of the contract, and not by clauses they do not apply in practice. The paragraph stops at this principle: it does not say in so many words which party then bears the exchange rate risk, and it does not re-price the transaction.
Key takeaway
A contractual allocation of risk counts only as far as the parties apply it. Where contract and conduct differ in a way that is economically significant and that third parties would price in, conduct, seen against the contract terms the parties do follow, should generally be treated as the best evidence of what they intended (¶1.88).

Related: Section D.1.2.1.4 (step 4: interpreting steps 1-3) · Section D.1.1 (the contractual terms of the transaction) · Example 7 in Annex I to Chapter VI (contractual risk contradicted by who bears the costs)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →