Risk analysis in six steps

Example 10 — Owning an asset without controlling its risks

Chapter I · Example 3 (risk) · ¶1.85, 1.92, 1.103, 1.106 · Company A · Company B · Company C

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
Company A owns a tangible asset and contracts with unrelated customers for its use, but its contribution is limited to financing the asset's cost. Company B decided on the investment and specified the asset, and Company C decides how it is used and negotiates with customers. What is Company A entitled to, and who bears an unexpected loss?
Companies B and C
B decides on the investment and specifies the asset · C decides on its use and deals with customers
investment and utilisation decisions
Company A
Legal owner of the asset · finances its cost
use of the asset
Unrelated customers
Contract with Company A for the use of the asset

Companies A, B and C belong to the same group. Company A's contract for the provision of services with Company C does not address the assumption of utilisation risk.

  1. Company B, a group company, identifies and evaluates commercial opportunities, assesses the asset's anticipated useful life and decides that investing in the asset is appropriate.
  2. Company B specifies the asset and the unique features it needs, arranges for it to be constructed accordingly and arranges for Company A to acquire it.
  3. Company A acquires ownership of the tangible asset, providing financing for an amount equal to its cost, and enters into contracts with unrelated customers for its use.
  4. A contract for the provision of services exists between Company A and another group company, Company C. It is silent on whether Company A, as owner of the asset, assumes the utilisation risk.
  5. Company C decides how the asset is utilised, markets what the asset can do to third-party customers, negotiates their contracts and makes sure the asset is delivered and properly installed.
A

Company A, the legal owner, assumes the utilisation risk, consistently with its contractual arrangements with Company C. It lacks any capability to decide on investing in the asset or exploiting it, and it does not evaluate the financing opportunity, its pricing or the protection of its investment. All three companies have the financial capacity for their respective risks.

Who bears the risks of the asset, and what return is left for Company A?

OECD analysis · No more than risk-free
Company A's assumption of utilisation risk fits its contractual arrangements with Company C (step 4(i)), but it has no decision-making function that lets it control the risks of investing in and exploiting the asset (step 4(ii)). Those risks are therefore aligned with Companies B and C, which control them. Company A contributes only financing equal to the cost of the asset and cannot control even the risk of that financial investment, so it is entitled to no more than a risk-free return; the risk attached to the financial asset is allocated to Company B. Company A could be entitled to less, for instance where the transaction is disregarded under Section D.2, and an assessment of commercial rationality may be necessary.
B

Company A, the legal owner, controls neither the investment risk nor the utilisation risk and is entitled to no more than a risk-free return. The asset is then unexpectedly destroyed, which results in an unanticipated loss.

To whom is the unanticipated loss allocated for transfer pricing purposes?

OECD analysis · Not Company A's loss
A party that, once the steps have been applied, neither assumes a risk nor contributes to its control is not entitled to unanticipated profits from that risk and is not required to bear unanticipated losses. Neither is therefore allocated to Company A. For transfer pricing purposes, the loss from an unexpected destruction of the asset would fall on whichever company or companies control the investment risk, contribute to that control and have the financial capacity to assume the risk; ¶1.106 does not name them. They would still owe Company A the return it is entitled to under ¶1.103.
Key takeaway
Legal ownership of an asset does not bring its risks or its returns to a party that controls none of them. A party whose only contribution is funding, and which does not control even the financing risk, is entitled to no more than a risk-free return and neither gains nor loses from unanticipated outcomes.

Related: ¶1.98 (step 5: allocation of risk to the enterprise with control and financial capacity) · Section D.2 (recognition of the accurately delineated transaction) · ¶1.104 and ¶6.60–6.64 (funding and the risks of the activity funded)

Test yourself on this example, question by question.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →