When PS is appropriate
Example 8 — Contract manufacturing — no unique contribution by B
Annex II Ch.II · Example 8 · ¶38–41 · M Group
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
Company A directs the manufacturing of electronic devices subcontracted to Company B. B follows A's instructions, sources inputs (including a key component from A), and sells finished goods back to A. B has specific tooling and no other customer, so it is integrated with A — but its risks are not economically significant. Method?
The parties
Company A (parent)
Exclusive distribution rights · directs manufacturing · key component supplierfinished goods
Company B
Contract manufacturer · specific tooling · sole customer is AWhat happens
- Company A subcontracts manufacturing of electronic devices to Company B.
- Company B follows Company A's directions to produce the devices.
- Company B sources and supplies most materials; a key component is sourced from Company A.
- Company B has invested in tooling specifically adapted to the devices and has no other customer.
- Company B sells the finished goods to Company A, which markets and distributes to unrelated customers.
Analysis
Company B brings nothing unique or valuable; its risks aren't economically significant. There's some integration with Company A and B has only one customer — but B can still be benchmarked against comparable contract manufacturers.
Is profit split the right method for B?
OECD analysis · One-sided method on Company B
Per Annex II Ch.II · Example 8 (¶41), although B is integrated with and dependent on A, B makes no unique and valuable contribution and its risks are not economically significant. Comparable uncontrolled transactions enable a reliable one-sided method (e.g. cost-plus or TNMM on B). Integration alone is not enough — the integration indicator must come with the inability to reliably one-side either party.
Key takeaway
Operational integration and customer concentration do not, by themselves, trigger profit split. The decisive question is whether reliable comparables exist for either party's contribution.
Related: ¶2.127 (when PS is not appropriate) · Example 4 (companion — limited B-side contribution)