When PS is appropriate

Example 7 — Trade facilitation — joint, seamless service across borders

Annex II Ch.II · Example 7 · ¶34–37 · LM Corporation

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
Companies L (Country L) and M (Country M) jointly provide cross-border freight-forwarding and customs brokerage to unrelated customers. They use a shared IT system, perform the same functions in mirror geographies, and depend on each other to complete each transaction. Pricing exists for the joint activity — but not for L or M separately. Method?
Company L (Country L)
Trade facilitation, freight forwarding, customs broking
joint service to external customers
Company M (Country M)
Same functions in mirror geography · shared IT
  1. Companies L and M jointly provide trade facilitation, freight forwarding and customs broking to external customers.
  2. They perform the same value-adding functions in mirror geographies, depending on each other for the success of each transaction.
  3. They jointly purchased and continue improving an integrated goods-tracking IT system.
  4. Customers pay based on volume and weight. LM's value proposition: competitive pricing through efficiency, scale, scope and seamless cross-border integration.

There are external comparables for the joint service, but L and M are so tightly integrated that a one-sided method can't price either side standalone. They probably also share the main risks.

Which method best prices L and M?

OECD analysis · Profit split — actual profits if risks shared
Per Annex II Ch.II · Example 7 (¶36–37), the high integration and interdependence make profit split the most appropriate method, and where economically significant risks are also shared, a profit split of actual profits is likely appropriate. Applying TNMM separately on L or M overlooks that the comparable pricing exists only for the joint activity — not for either side standalone.
Key takeaway
The choice between anticipated and actual profits to split is itself driven by the risk allocation. Shared risk points to actual; separately assumed risk points to anticipated.

Related: ¶2.137–2.143 (high integration · shared risk) · ¶2.158–2.162 (anticipated vs. actual profits)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →