Low value-adding services

Example 28 — Credit risk analysis in two different groups

Draft (June 2026) · Main text · ¶7.81 · Shoe manufacturer · investment banking group

OECD discussion draft, June 2026 (not final)
At a glance
Company A, a shoe manufacturer, analyses the credit risk of its subsidiary B's customers from reports bought from a credit reporting agency. Company X performs credit risk analysis for a worldwide investment banking group, using internally developed confidential models. Is the service low value-adding in both settings?
  1. Company A, in Country A, manufactures shoes and distributes them wholesale in the North-West region. The same shoes are distributed wholesale in the South-East region by B, A's wholly-owned subsidiary in Country B.
  2. In the course of its operations, A routinely analyses the credit risk of its customers, working from reports it buys from a credit reporting agency. It carries out the same analysis of B's customers on B's behalf, with the same methods and approaches.
  3. Separately, a worldwide investment banking group has a subsidiary, Company X. Company X assesses the credit risk of potential counterparties to transactions in financial derivatives contracts and draws up credit reports for the group.
  4. The group uses Company X's credit analyses when it sets the prices of financial derivatives for its clients. Company X's personnel have developed special expertise and work with confidential credit risk analysis models, algorithms and software that were developed internally.
A

Company A, a shoe manufacturer and wholesale distributor, routinely analyses the credit risk of its own customers from reports bought from a credit reporting agency. It performs the same analysis of the customers of its wholly-owned subsidiary B, on B's behalf, using the same methods and approaches.

Is the credit risk analysis that A performs for B a low value-adding intra-group service?

OECD analysis · Could reasonably be low value-adding
On these facts and circumstances, the draft finds it reasonable to conclude that A is providing B with a low value-adding intra-group service. A's business is making shoes and distributing them wholesale; the credit risk analysis is something it does routinely in the course of that business, working from reports bought from a credit reporting agency. The draft gives the example to illustrate that low value-adding services should not include services that are part of the MNE's core business.
B

Company X analyses the credit risk of potential counterparties to financial derivatives transactions and prepares credit reports for its worldwide investment banking group, which uses the analyses to set the prices of financial derivatives for its clients. Its personnel work with confidential credit risk analysis models, algorithms and software that were developed internally, and have built up special expertise.

Is Company X's credit risk analysis a low value-adding intra-group service?

OECD analysis · Not low value-adding here
For Company X the draft comes to the opposite view: on the facts and circumstances of the case, one could not conclude that its service to the banking group is a low value-adding intra-group service. The group uses the analyses to establish the prices of financial derivatives for its clients, and Company X's personnel have developed special expertise and work with internally developed confidential models, algorithms and software. The draft does not say which element of the definition is decisive. It presents the pair to show that superficially similar services may or may not be low value-adding depending on their context: such services should not be part of the MNE's core business, and a service may also fail to qualify because, in its context, it creates significant risk or unique and valuable intangibles.
Key takeaway
Whether a service is low value-adding depends on its context, not on its label. The same kind of work can be routine support in one group and, in another, part of the core business or a source of significant risk or unique and valuable intangibles.

Related: Section E.1 (definition of low value-adding intra-group services) · ¶7.76 (the elements of the definition) · The same two examples are in the 2022 Guidelines at ¶7.50

Test yourself on this example, question by question.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →