Charging approaches
Example 27 — Allocation key: one new market among mature ones
Draft (June 2026) · Main text · ¶7.48 · Regional marketing centre
OECD discussion draft, June 2026 (not final)At a glance
A regional marketing centre provides marketing services to several recipients. One of them is in a new market; all the others are in mature markets. Is a key based on actual sales in the year of the services a suitable way to allocate the charge, or would the share of time spent on each market match the expected benefit more closely?
The parties
Regional marketing centre
Provides marketing servicesmarketing services
One service recipient
New marketAll other service recipients
Mature marketsWhat happens
- A regional marketing centre provides marketing services to several service recipients.
- One of the recipients is in a new market.
- All the other recipients are in mature markets.
Analysis
The charge is to be allocated among the recipients, one of which is in a new market while the others are in mature markets. One candidate key is the actual sales accrued in the year of the marketing services; the other is each market's share of the time spent.
Which key is more likely to match the charges to the benefit the recipients can expect?
OECD analysis · Time spent may fit better
The draft says an allocation key should rest on an appropriate measure of usage and expected benefit, and that it must be workable in practice while still accurate enough to keep the intra-group charges from departing significantly from the expected benefits. Where one recipient is in a new market and the others are in mature ones, it says a key based on actual sales in the year of the services may be inappropriate, whereas a key that follows the share of time spent on each market may align more closely with the benefit the recipients can expect. Both statements are qualified with "may": the draft does not rule out a sales key in general, and it does not spell out its reasoning.
Key takeaway
An allocation key must be practical, but it must also follow usage and expected benefit closely enough to avoid significant disparities between benefits and charges. A key that is easy to measure, such as the year's sales, may fail that test when the recipients' markets are at different stages.
Related: Section C.1.2 (indirect-charge approaches) · ¶7.47 (what any indirect charge has to satisfy)