Mark-up & pass-through
Example 19 — 5% safe harbour does not bind non-LVA services
Draft (June 2026) · Annex I · Example 19 · ¶81–83
OECD discussion draft, June 2026 (not final)At a glance
Company A charges a 3% mark-up on total costs for services that don't qualify as low value-adding (LVA). On audit, the tax administration argues the 5% LVA safe harbour should be a floor. Is it?
The parties
Company A
Service provider · 3% ROTC mark-upservice fees
Group recipients
Receive services that don't qualify as LVAWhat happens
- Company A renders services to other group members and applies a 3% ROTC mark-up using TNMM.
- The services do not meet the criteria for low value-adding intra-group services under Section E.
- On audit, the local tax administration argues the mark-up should be at least 5% by reference to the LVA safe harbour.
Analysis
The OECD's 5% mark-up is a simplified safe harbour designed for genuinely low value-adding services. Outside that scope, the Guidelines say it shouldn't be used as a benchmark without justification.
Does the 5% safe harbour act as a floor for other services?
OECD analysis · 5% is not a floor
The fact that services do not satisfy the definition of low value-adding intra-group services does not imply that a higher mark-up must necessarily be applied. The arm's length mark-up for services outside the LVA scope requires a separate transfer pricing analysis, taking into account functions, assets and risks. The arm's length rate could be above, equal to, or even below 5%.
Key takeaway
The LVA safe harbour is a simplified expedient for a narrowly defined population. Outside that population, the answer comes from a normal arm's-length analysis — not by reference to the safe harbour rate.
Related: Section E (low value-adding services) · Chapter VII §7.92