Selecting the TP method

Example 18 — TNMM with Core IP — wrong tested party

Draft (June 2026) · Annex I · Example 18 · ¶77–80 · Group XYZ · Construction

OECD discussion draft, June 2026 (not final)
At a glance
Company P, the parent, has decades of proprietary construction know-how ("Core IP"). It provides oversight and access to Core IP to affiliates running large projects. Affiliates apply TNMM treating Company P as the tested party, against comparables that do not develop or share comparable IP. Reliable?
Company P (parent)
Decades of proprietary Core IP · oversight
oversight & access to Core IP
Group XYZ affiliates
Run construction projects for external clients
  1. Group XYZ contracts with external clients for large construction projects worldwide.
  2. Company P develops Core IP — designs, methods, procedures, blueprints, training, technical advice.
  3. On each project, Company P oversees progress and gives affiliates access to Core IP without explicit licenses or transfers.
  4. Affiliates price Company P's services using TNMM, treating Company P as the tested party, against service providers that do not develop or provide access to comparable IP.

The comparables look like Company P on the surface — but none develops or provides anything like the Core IP.

Can Company P be the tested party here?

OECD analysis · TNMM unreliable with P as tested party
It is not appropriate to select Company P as the tested party because the purported comparables differ materially in respect of developing and providing access to Core IP. This makes Company P's TNMM unreliable because it lacks consideration of the value of Core IP in connection with the services. See paragraph 2.65 of Chapter II.
Key takeaway
The tested party is normally the one whose role is less complex. A party that contributes uniquely valuable IP is rarely the right tested party — that choice strips the analysis of the very value the parties are pricing.

Related: Chapter II §2.65 (tested-party selection) · Chapter VI (intangibles)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →