Services and intangibles
Example 25 — Strategic advice built on proprietary know-how
Draft (June 2026) · Main text · ¶7.41 · MNE Group X · MNE Group Y
OECD discussion draft, June 2026 (not final)At a glance
After MNE Group X acquires MNE Group Y, Parent Co (the parent company of MNE Group X) gives the new subsidiaries strategic advice and information built on its proprietary know-how, frameworks and methodologies. Is this only a service, or can it in effect also transfer know-how to the new subsidiaries?
The parties
Parent Co
Parent company of MNE Group X · proprietary know-howstrategic advice and information
New subsidiaries
Acquired with MNE Group YWhat happens
- MNE Group Y is acquired by MNE Group X.
- The parent company of the acquiring group, Parent Co, then gives the new subsidiaries strategic advice and information.
- For this it relies on its proprietary know-how, frameworks and methodologies: for example pricing frameworks, risk assessment tools or unique market entry models.
Analysis
Parent Co's advice draws on its proprietary know-how, frameworks and methodologies. The new subsidiaries may, as a result, become able to apply and adapt that know-how on their own.
Is Parent Co's advice to the new subsidiaries only a service?
OECD analysis · Possible transfer of know-how
The draft uses the example to show that it may be difficult to tell the provision of services apart from a transfer of intangibles or of rights in intangibles. The advice Parent Co gives rests on know-how, frameworks and methodologies that are proprietary to it. As a consequence, the subsidiaries may gain the ability to apply and adapt that know-how independently, which the draft describes as effectively a transfer of know-how to them. The draft stops there: it does not say how the arrangement should be priced, and refers to Annex I, Example 16.
Key takeaway
Advice that draws on proprietary know-how can do more than serve the recipient. If it leaves the recipient able to apply and adapt that know-how on its own, the know-how has in effect been transferred, and the line between a service and a transfer of intangibles may be hard to draw.
Related: Section B.3 (provision of services in connection with other transactions) · Annex I, Example 16 (machine learning model; services resulting in transfers of intangibles)