Services and intangibles

Example 25 — Strategic advice built on proprietary know-how

Draft (June 2026) · Main text · ¶7.41 · MNE Group X · MNE Group Y

OECD discussion draft, June 2026 (not final)
At a glance
After MNE Group X acquires MNE Group Y, Parent Co (the parent company of MNE Group X) gives the new subsidiaries strategic advice and information built on its proprietary know-how, frameworks and methodologies. Is this only a service, or can it in effect also transfer know-how to the new subsidiaries?
Parent Co
Parent company of MNE Group X · proprietary know-how
strategic advice and information
New subsidiaries
Acquired with MNE Group Y
  1. MNE Group Y is acquired by MNE Group X.
  2. The parent company of the acquiring group, Parent Co, then gives the new subsidiaries strategic advice and information.
  3. For this it relies on its proprietary know-how, frameworks and methodologies: for example pricing frameworks, risk assessment tools or unique market entry models.

Parent Co's advice draws on its proprietary know-how, frameworks and methodologies. The new subsidiaries may, as a result, become able to apply and adapt that know-how on their own.

Is Parent Co's advice to the new subsidiaries only a service?

OECD analysis · Possible transfer of know-how
The draft uses the example to show that it may be difficult to tell the provision of services apart from a transfer of intangibles or of rights in intangibles. The advice Parent Co gives rests on know-how, frameworks and methodologies that are proprietary to it. As a consequence, the subsidiaries may gain the ability to apply and adapt that know-how independently, which the draft describes as effectively a transfer of know-how to them. The draft stops there: it does not say how the arrangement should be priced, and refers to Annex I, Example 16.
Key takeaway
Advice that draws on proprietary know-how can do more than serve the recipient. If it leaves the recipient able to apply and adapt that know-how on its own, the know-how has in effect been transferred, and the line between a service and a transfer of intangibles may be hard to draw.

Related: Section B.3 (provision of services in connection with other transactions) · Annex I, Example 16 (machine learning model; services resulting in transfers of intangibles)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →