Selecting the TP method
Example 15 — Contract research vs. unique R&D
Draft (June 2026) · Annex I · Example 15 · ¶62–68 · Group X · Pharma
OECD discussion draft, June 2026 (not final)At a glance
The same pharma group runs two R&D arrangements. One is tightly directed by Company A. The other gives the researcher real autonomy and unique IP. Should the same TP method price them both?
The parties
Company A
Global R&D leader · owns intangiblesdirected work
Company B
Contract research under directionautonomous R&D
Company C
Autonomous early-stage research · own IPWhat happens
- Company A directs and controls group R&D, owns the resulting intangibles and pre-existing IP it uses to manage R&D.
- Company B performs research exclusively for Company A under a detailed service agreement that defines scope, protocols, reporting, and IP ownership.
- Separately, Company C conducts early-stage exploratory research under a broad framework — it chooses areas, assesses feasibility, decides on continuation, and uses its own specialised IP.
The questions
A
Company B has almost no discretion and doesn't bear the risk of research failure. The parties stick to the contract.
Which method prices Company B?
OECD analysis · Cost-plus / TNMM
Taking into account functions, assets and risks, the arrangement is characterised as contract research services from Company B to Company A. The services may be appropriately priced using the cost-plus method or the TNMM with a cost-based profit level indicator.
B
Company C picks its own research areas, assesses feasibility and decides what to continue, using its own specialised IP. Both Company A and C bring unique, valuable IP, and they work in tightly integrated fashion.
Which method prices Company C?
OECD analysis · Profit split
After analysing functions, assets and risks, both parties make unique and valuable contributions, and their operations are highly integrated such that intangibles cannot be utilised separately. The conditions for the transactional profit split method are met. It may be the most appropriate method for pricing the transaction.
Key takeaway
Method selection follows the substance of the parties' contributions and integration — not the form of the contract or the industry label. "R&D services" can mean very different things across affiliates of the same group.
Related: Chapter II (profit split conditions) · Example 13 (milestone pricing)